Armoured Combat Draft notes:Melee Weapon Standards: Difference between revisions

From SCA Lochac
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
Line 9: Line 9:
:Maximum weapon length is reduced from 12 feet to 9 feet
:Maximum weapon length is reduced from 12 feet to 9 feet
;Reason
;Reason
:Game play rule change at Society level. The six kingdoms (including Lochac) that still allowed 12 foot all reported that there would be no issue returning to 9 foot.
:Society rule change - Game play rule change at Society level. The six kingdoms (including Lochac) that still allowed 12 foot all reported that there would be no issue returning to 9 foot.
;For notes section
;For notes section
:November 2023 - To ensure consistency between kingdoms, the Society armoured combat rules were changed in October 2023 to reduce the maximum length for two handed weapons (particularly spears) to 2.7m (9 feet). Lochac was one of only 6 kingdoms in the Known World that permitted the use of 12 foot spears in their kingdom rules.
:November 2023 - To ensure consistency between kingdoms, the Society armoured combat rules were changed in October 2023 to reduce the maximum length for two handed weapons (particularly spears) to 2.7m (9 feet). Lochac was one of only 6 kingdoms in the Known World that permitted the use of 12 foot spears in their kingdom rules.
<hr>
;Was 8.3.4 in Fibreglass spears
:
;Was
:2" Mandrake™ tips are not legal on fibreglass spears.
;Now
:Removed and subsequent rules renumbered.
;Reason
:Society rule change - 2 inch Mandrake tips are not legal on any weapon over 7 1/2 feet. Now covered by rule 8.4.3.5
<hr>
;Was 8.3.11, now 8.3.10 in Fibreglass spears
:
;Was
:Total spear length must not exceed 3.65m (12 feet).
;Now
:Removed and subsequent rules renumbered
;Reason
:Now covered by rule 8.2.3
<hr>
;Table 8.2 and 8.4.2 in Thrusting tips
:
;Was
:Low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons must be constructed of at least 19.1 mm (3/4 inch) of resilient material. They must provide at least 9.53 mm (3/8 inch) of progressive give across the face of the thrusting tip without allowing contact with the rigid tip of the weapon.
;Now
:Low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons must be constructed of at least 12 mm (1/2 inch) of resilient material. They must provide progressive give across the face of the thrusting tip without allowing contact with the rigid tip of the weapon.
;Functional change
:Reduction of padding thickness for low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons from 3/4 inch to 1/2 inch.  The amount of progressive give is less important at this scale, as long as there is some
;Reason
:Society rule change - The 1/2 inch thickness has been successfully used in Trimaris for 10 years with no issues.
;For notes section
;November 2023 - A Society armoured combat rule change in October 2023 reduced the minimum thickness of low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons to 12 mm. This was successfully used in Trimaris for 10 years with no issues.
<hr>
;8.4.3.5 in High-profile Thrusting Tips
:
;Was
:2" Mandrake™ tips are not legal on fibreglass spears.
;Now
:2" Mandrake™ tips are not legal on weapons greater than 2.28 m (7 1/2 ft) in length.
;Functional change
:2" Mandrake™ tips are no longer legal on any weapons greater than 2.28 m (7 1/2 ft) in length, not just illegal for fibreglass spears
;Reason
:The tips can fold and penetrate the bar grill of a helmet. The manufacturer advises that they were not designed for use on weapons like spears.

Revision as of 09:31, 26 October 2023

Changes in Chapter 8 for v 3.3.1

8.2.3.6 in Two-handed weapons
Was
The total length of a two-handed weapon must not exceed 3.65m (12 feet). If it exceeds 2.28m (7 1/2 feet) it must not be used for cutting or smashing and must be used for thrusting only.
Now
The total length of a two-handed weapon must not exceed 2.7m (9 feet). If it exceeds 2.28m (7 1/2 feet) it must not be used for cutting or smashing and must be used for thrusting only.
Functional change
Maximum weapon length is reduced from 12 feet to 9 feet
Reason
Society rule change - Game play rule change at Society level. The six kingdoms (including Lochac) that still allowed 12 foot all reported that there would be no issue returning to 9 foot.
For notes section
November 2023 - To ensure consistency between kingdoms, the Society armoured combat rules were changed in October 2023 to reduce the maximum length for two handed weapons (particularly spears) to 2.7m (9 feet). Lochac was one of only 6 kingdoms in the Known World that permitted the use of 12 foot spears in their kingdom rules.

Was 8.3.4 in Fibreglass spears
Was
2" Mandrake™ tips are not legal on fibreglass spears.
Now
Removed and subsequent rules renumbered.
Reason
Society rule change - 2 inch Mandrake tips are not legal on any weapon over 7 1/2 feet. Now covered by rule 8.4.3.5

Was 8.3.11, now 8.3.10 in Fibreglass spears
Was
Total spear length must not exceed 3.65m (12 feet).
Now
Removed and subsequent rules renumbered
Reason
Now covered by rule 8.2.3

Table 8.2 and 8.4.2 in Thrusting tips
Was
Low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons must be constructed of at least 19.1 mm (3/4 inch) of resilient material. They must provide at least 9.53 mm (3/8 inch) of progressive give across the face of the thrusting tip without allowing contact with the rigid tip of the weapon.
Now
Low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons must be constructed of at least 12 mm (1/2 inch) of resilient material. They must provide progressive give across the face of the thrusting tip without allowing contact with the rigid tip of the weapon.
Functional change
Reduction of padding thickness for low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons from 3/4 inch to 1/2 inch. The amount of progressive give is less important at this scale, as long as there is some
Reason
Society rule change - The 1/2 inch thickness has been successfully used in Trimaris for 10 years with no issues.
For notes section
November 2023 - A Society armoured combat rule change in October 2023 reduced the minimum thickness of low-profile thrusting tips on single-handed weapons to 12 mm. This was successfully used in Trimaris for 10 years with no issues.

8.4.3.5 in High-profile Thrusting Tips
Was
2" Mandrake™ tips are not legal on fibreglass spears.
Now
2" Mandrake™ tips are not legal on weapons greater than 2.28 m (7 1/2 ft) in length.
Functional change
2" Mandrake™ tips are no longer legal on any weapons greater than 2.28 m (7 1/2 ft) in length, not just illegal for fibreglass spears
Reason
The tips can fold and penetrate the bar grill of a helmet. The manufacturer advises that they were not designed for use on weapons like spears.