Fencing Draft notes:Inspections: Difference between revisions

From SCA Lochac
Jump to navigation Jump to search
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
==Changes for v6.0==
===Changes for Inspections===
 
;Was 3.2 in Rules for marshals, now 12.1 Inspections - General
:Moved be with other inspection information.
<hr>
 
;Was 3.2.1, now 12.1.1 in General
:
;Was
:If you are an authorised Fencing Marshal, you can check equipment to make sure it complies with the rules. Information about fencing equipment is in Chapter 5 - Rules for equipment.
;Now
:If you are an authorised Fencing Marshal, you can check equipment to make sure it complies with the rules. Requirements for fencing equipment are in Protective equipment and Weapons and defensive equipment.
;Reason
:Updated links to updated sections.
<hr>
 
;Was 3.2.2, now 12.1.2 in General
:
;Was
:Your job includes:
:*making sure each fencer is wearing all of their protective clothing and equipment, and that it is fitted properly, with no skin visible and only incidental gaps between each item.
;Now
:Your job includes:
:*making sure each fencer is wearing all of their protective clothing and equipment, and that it is fitted properly, with only incidental gaps between each item.
;Functional change
:No visible skin is not a requirement as incidental gaps are permitted.
;Reason
:No visible skin is not a requirement as incidental gaps are permitted.
<hr>
 
;Was 3.2.4, now 12.1.4
:
;Was
:Some defensive objects are classified as non-standard. You are responsible for deciding if non-standard equipment complies with the rules and can be used on the field.
;Now
:Some defensive objects are classified as non-standard. The Fencing Marshal-in-Charge is responsible for deciding if non-standard equipment complies with the rules and can be used on the field.
;Functional change
:The Fencing Marshal-in-Charge is the one who can decide on non-standard equipment, rather than just any Fencing Marshal
;Reason
:Prevents marshal hunting to allow an item.
<hr>
===6.2.3.1.a===
===6.2.3.1.a===
;Was
;Was

Revision as of 08:50, 22 June 2023

Changes for Inspections

Was 3.2 in Rules for marshals, now 12.1 Inspections - General
Moved be with other inspection information.

Was 3.2.1, now 12.1.1 in General
Was
If you are an authorised Fencing Marshal, you can check equipment to make sure it complies with the rules. Information about fencing equipment is in Chapter 5 - Rules for equipment.
Now
If you are an authorised Fencing Marshal, you can check equipment to make sure it complies with the rules. Requirements for fencing equipment are in Protective equipment and Weapons and defensive equipment.
Reason
Updated links to updated sections.

Was 3.2.2, now 12.1.2 in General
Was
Your job includes:
  • making sure each fencer is wearing all of their protective clothing and equipment, and that it is fitted properly, with no skin visible and only incidental gaps between each item.
Now
Your job includes:
  • making sure each fencer is wearing all of their protective clothing and equipment, and that it is fitted properly, with only incidental gaps between each item.
Functional change
No visible skin is not a requirement as incidental gaps are permitted.
Reason
No visible skin is not a requirement as incidental gaps are permitted.

Was 3.2.4, now 12.1.4
Was
Some defensive objects are classified as non-standard. You are responsible for deciding if non-standard equipment complies with the rules and can be used on the field.
Now
Some defensive objects are classified as non-standard. The Fencing Marshal-in-Charge is responsible for deciding if non-standard equipment complies with the rules and can be used on the field.
Functional change
The Fencing Marshal-in-Charge is the one who can decide on non-standard equipment, rather than just any Fencing Marshal
Reason
Prevents marshal hunting to allow an item.

6.2.3.1.a

Was
For rubber-headed spears, check that the tip is flexible, and returns substantially to its original shape within 3 seconds.
Now
Check that the rubber tip is flexible, and returns substantially to its original shape within 3 seconds.
Functional change
None
Reason
Only rubber-headed spears may be used.
For notes section
April 2023 - Process updated to remove reference to steel-headed spears.

6.2.3.1.b

Was
For metal-headed spears, follow the inspection methods for a bladed weapon.
Now
Removed
Reason
Metal-headed spears are no longer permitted

6.2.3.1.b (replacement)

Was
Not in rules
Now
A marshal should not use significant force to make a spear head bend; you should not need more pressure than can be comfortably applied by the wrist. If in doubt and where possible, a second marshal should be used to judge the flexibility of the spear head.
Functional change
Sets a more objective measure of flexibility
Reason
Most objects can be subject to significant tensile strength and many can return to their original shape within 3 seconds. As written, and as evidenced by some newer spear head designs, a marshal can apply a significant tensile load to a spear head (up to and including significant pressure from a hip whole body movement) to make a spear head "pass". This is unacceptable and unsafe. This is a stop-gap solution until a broader Society flex-test can be developed (underway).
For notes section
April 2023 - Spear head flex testing - Most objects can be subject to significant tensile strength and many can return to their original shape within 3 seconds. As previously written, a marshal could apply a significant tensile load to a spear head (up to and including significant pressure from a hip whole body movement) to make a spear head "pass". This was unacceptable and unsafe. The current wording is is a stop-gap solution until a broader Society flex-test can be developed.

6.2.3.2.a

Was
Check that the haft is made of appropriate material (rattan for rubber-headed spears; wood or rattan for metal-headed spears).
Now
Check that the haft is made of rattan.
Reason
Metal-headed spears are no longer permitted

6.2.3.2.b

Was
Check that the rattan haft is the appropriate diameter (between 28.5 mm and 35 mm).
Now
Check that the haft is between 28.5 mm and 35 mm in diameter.
Reason
Rattan is the only material allowed for spears.

6.2.3.2.c

Was
Check that the spear is the appropriate length (no longer than 275 cm for rubber-headed spears, or 244 cm for metal-headed spears).
Now
Check that the spear is no longer than 275 cm.
Reason
Metal-headed spears are no longer permitted